[Debconfsubs-team] [Debconf-video] A couple of petitions. Syncing subs files and consistency in video.debian.org

[alberto fuentes]

On Wed, Aug 3, 2016 at 12:58 PM, Holger Levsen <holger at layer-acht.org>
wrote:

> On Sat, Jul 30, 2016 at 09:39:02AM +0200, alberto fuentes wrote:
> > > > Can I have the subtitles sync with debian-meetings?
> > > what does this mean in practice, what needs to be done?
> > manually erase any reminds of subs since the latest version with new name
> > schema (mostly remove subtitles folders):
>
> are you talking about debian-meetings or debian-meetings/debconf16 ?
>

debian-mettings... Right now, the best available version for every subtitle
is the one on the subs repo with the new schema. wip and languages folders
have been removed since they are now implied in the subtitle file name

thus, find -name '*srt' on the root and remove those folders and then sync
the new ones


>
> >
> find -name '*srt' and remove those folders >
> > copy files. Roughly:
> >     git clone subtitles; cd subtitles; for i in */; do for j in $i*/; do
> cp
> > $i$j/* ../$i$j/subs; done; done
>
> I'd actually prefer a rsyncable location but this might work.
>

I separated the subtitles folder from everything else yesterday to ease the
copy. In the subs repo now theres a subtitles folder that contains only
subtitles with the following pattern: year/event/subtitles_files*.srt

In the past subs has been added to a sub folder on the event folder for no
particular reason. Next to the video file gives them more visibility to
what is actually available. On the other hand, one subtitles folder on the
root is easier to sync. Whatever you feel is better is okay

rsync with -delete would be best for now due to the versioning on the file
name


>
> > Some doubts come to mind tho:
> > - I wonder if there is a way for me to trigger this copy without
> bothering
> > anybody
>
> rather not
>

I will try to ping somebody on irc when this needs to be done again.
Hopefully once a process is established, this will be quicker :)



> > - versioning of the subs files are implied on the file name. That means,
> > every new version the file name changes and old version needs to be
> > removed. I asking about the better way to fix this. Some rsync with
> > -delete?
>
> I wouldnt do this. The filename should stay the same, no matter the
> version. You have git for versioning.
>

I tested it and the versioning on the name is not a problem for the players
to automatically recognize the language and the subtitle file if the are
next to the video file. If this didnt work, this would had been a major
concern for me not to do it

I was aware of the awkwardness when I decided to do it, but did it anyway
because we need to keep in sync git and amara files. I also think is useful
for users to be able to tell just by looking at the subtitle that theres a
newer version available.

The other solution was to create a metadata file with the versioning, but I
dont think it has any other advantages other than avoiding --delete when
rsyncing the folders

Thanks for looking into this!

PS: The amara automatic syncing is almost finished btw
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.alioth.debian.org/pipermail/debconfsubs-team/attachments/20160803/d022b8b6/attachment-0001.html>