Debian NEW: automated review of duckdb 2.0.0+dfsg-1
dfsg-team at debian.org
dfsg-team at debian.org
Tue Oct 27 16:03:15 GMT 2026
Hi,
Your upload of duckdb 2.0.0+dfsg-1 to the NEW queue has had an automated review: an LLM-based check of its licensing and packaging, run by the DFSG team using the Debian Inference service. It is not a decision on the package, and - like other LLM-based work - it can be wrong.
It found 5 blocker, 9 important, 4 minor issues:
- [blocker] [licensing] extension/tpch/dbgen is the non-free TPC End User License Agreement and is compiled into libduckdb.so
- [blocker] [licensing] extension/tpcds/dsdgen carries the TPC 'Legal Notice', which reserves all rights and grants no permission to copy or distribute
- [blocker] [licensing] Files: * names only Stichting DuckDB Foundation while src/ contains MIT code from CWI, Martin Ankerl and salesforce.com
- [blocker] [licensing] BSD-3-Clause files are declared Expat: test/sqlite/termcolor.hpp (Ihor Kalnytskyi) and third_party/hyperloglog/sds.{cpp,hpp} (Sanfilippo, Oran Agra, Redis Labs)
- [blocker] [licensing] Unicode data licences are unrecorded: utf8proc_data.cpp (UCD) and extension/icu/collation/generated/collation_data.cpp (CLDR 48, UCD 17.0.0)
- [important] [licensing] third_party/jemalloc/include/msvc_compat/C99/stdint.h is BSD-3-Clause (Alexander Chemeris) under the BSD-2-Clause jemalloc stanza
- [important] [licensing] third_party/concurrentqueue/lightweightsemaphore.h is zlib-licensed (Jeff Preshing), not BSD-2-Clause or BSL-1.0
- [important] [licensing] third_party/re2/util/{rune.cc,utf.h} carry the Lucent/Plan 9 notice, not BSD-3-Clause, and Lucent Technologies is unnamed
- [important] [licensing] third_party/miniz/miniz.cpp contains Martin Raiber's Expat code and an Unlicense public-domain portion, declared Expat only
- [important] [licensing] tools/swift/* is declared 'Apache Arrow Authors, Apache-2.0 or Expat' but is Stichting DuckDB Foundation Expat plus Apple's Apache-2.0 with Swift Runtime Library Exception
- [important] [licensing] MIT/BSL files covered only by `Files: *`: extension_external/ui/third_party/httplib and extension_external/*/database-connector/test/catch
- [important] [licensing] Third-party test data (AdventureWorks, Chinook, Sakila, walmart sales) is not addressed by debian/copyright
- [important] [packaging] The autopkgtest 'ui' test needs the internet: it proxies through the extension to https://ui.duckdb.org
- [important] [packaging] quack and ui autopkgtests open TCP ports without Restrictions: isolation-container
- [minor] [licensing] scripts/ LLVM files and the PostgreSQL libpq diff are Apache-2.0 WITH LLVM-exception and PostgreSQL-licensed, unnamed
- [minor] [licensing] third_party/pcg is Apache-2.0 OR MIT, not Expat alone, and its Apache text is absent from the tree
- [minor] [licensing] Source: names only duckdb/duckdb although the tarball also contains six extension repositories
- [minor] [packaging] sqlite_scanner builds its own SQLite 3.38.1 amalgamation although Debian ships libsqlite3
You can read the full review here:
https://dfsg-new-queue.debian.org/reviews/duckdb#assistant-report
Please look at it, and respond by visiting the link below (you'll be asked to authenticate with Salsa first):
https://dfsg-new-queue.debian.org/llm-review/inu28O-wQgnBsl3Pj4BEJaFzNTfieXpD
There you may choose to reject the upload yourself, while you fix issues and re-upload, or add comments to clarify or dispute the review.
Your comments are for the DFSG team member who reviews the package, not for the LLM: it will not read them or reply. Tell the reviewer where you think the automated review is right or wrong, and why. Comments are public and shown with the review; you may use markdown, e.g. to link to clarifying information.
If you have any questions, please reply to this e-mail and someone from the
team will respond.
If you would rather not be e-mailed about these reviews, log in at https://dfsg-new-queue.debian.org
and say so on your profile page.
Thanks!
More information about the debian-science-maintainers
mailing list