[Freedombox-discuss] The "new" FreedomBox logo (Was: Re: Condemos: FBx UI & Potential Distro)

[Luka Marčetić]

On 02/28/2012 10:14 PM, Mathieu Jourdan wrote:
> Hi,
>
> Le 27 février 2012 23:41, Robert Martinez<mail at mray.de>  a écrit :
>> Find the new logo in all variants here: http://mray.de/FreedomBox-Logo.7z
>> Can somebody with access to the wiki please upload it there?
> I updated the wiki with the new logo. I also added a new page :
> https://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox/VisualIdentity
>
> Regards,
> Mathieu

Hello all,
I'm the author of the "gnu in a box" logo currently being used by the 
FreedomBox Foundation, as you can see at 
http://freedomboxfoundation.org/thanks/, and the Wikipedia description 
page for the image.
I was surprised to see today that Mathieu Jourdan has deleted this logo 
from the Debian wiki and replaced it with a butterfly design by Robert 
Martinez.
I might be out of the loop here, but was this change discussed, and 
found to be a wanted one? Also, what is the foundation's stance on it?

My patchwork might be crude, but I still prefer it to the butterfly. 
With all due respect to the work that Martinez has done, the butterfly 
does not aesthetically please me. To be clear, I'm aware that 
improvements on my design, or even a complete redesign are a 
possibility, however, I'm not sure the agreement was reached here. In 
fact, I'm not sure what would constitute an agreement in a matter such 
as this, since my suggestion for voting for consensus (older members 
might remember) was not implemented - by me or anyone else as far as I know.

Mathieu, please revert the changes made to the wiki, unless we agree(d) 
otherwise.

Thank you,
-Luka