[Pkg-acpi-devel] Bug#556903: Is acpi-support deprecated?
jrnieder at gmail.com
Wed Nov 18 08:34:20 UTC 2009
Hi ACPI team,
This likely reflects confusion on my part; please let me know.
I am a fan of the ability of Debian systems to cleanly shut down when
the "off" button is pressed. I believe you are the ones to thank for
this, so thank you.
Recently, I was surprised to learn upstream considers these scripts a
deprecated temporary solution:
So, a few questions:
1. What is the suggested replacement for these scripts? I know the
hotkey events should be being generated by in-kernel drivers, but what
process should respond to pressing the power button and tell init?
(Maybe this is gnome-power-manager. In that case, I guess a separate
bug is needed, requesting a gnome-power-manager-light build depending
on hal, dbus, libnotify, and no other X-related libraries.)
2. Would it be possible to direct users better in the package
description? I am imagining a notice somewhat along these lines:
This package is meant as a temporary solution to problems in
other packages. For suspend and hibernate support (even
without X), see gnome-power-manager. Laptop hotkeys should
generate key press events nowadays even without this package;
try it with ‘xev’ and see the ‘udev’ documentation if this is
Looking forward to your thoughts,
More information about the Pkg-acpi-devel