Bug#455769: same problem on wheezy + Thinkpad X220T

[Daniel Pocock]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256



On 28/03/13 18:59, Michael Biebl wrote:
> Am 28.03.2013 18:48, schrieb Daniel Pocock:
> 
>> I clearly understand your previous feedback and agree, that is
>> why I thought it might be helpful discussing this issue on
>> debian-devel, to get a feel for how the community feels about
>> this type of issue and it's severity for us and for users
> 
> discussing about bug severities doesn't get us one bit closer to a
> fix for this issue.

I agree - classifying a bug is just a first step before I do anything
more about an issue

> What we need is someone who can reliably reproduce the issue and
> help with debugging.
> 
> Fwiw, in wheezy, the relevant GNOME power management bits are all
> in the power plugin in gnome-settings-daemon, so
> gnome-power-manager would be the wrong component for this bug
> anyway (when talking about wheezy).

Thanks for this suggestion.  As noted in the bug, I checked the
settings using the CLI tool `gsettings'.  The GUI control panel
doesn't expose access to those settings.

Another reason I brought this to debian-devel is that there has been
debate about lid closing/suspend in the Gnome community and their
policy change in Gnome 3 appears to first hit Debian users with wheezy.

Looking at the system, I found /var/log/pm-suspend.log and I notice it
logs activity at 9:40 am yesterday (laptop woken from suspend)

It doesn't log anything in the evening at the time it overheated - the
next log entry is at 9:25am today when it went into suspend again.  So
it appears it didn't even try to suspend when the lid closed last
night and overheated (Mar 27 19:20):


Wed Mar 27 09:40:14 CET 2013: Finished.
Initial commandline parameters:
Thu Mar 28 09:25:51 CET 2013: Running hooks for suspend.
Running hook /usr/lib/pm-utils/sleep.d/000kernel-change suspend suspend:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/

iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJRVJrkAAoJEOm1uwJp1aqDNCgQAMWHWLIw0LiMJRncAMd9j+fW
XNt8mvLBb3gOHxTIjNI60rx074qxyOv+saz/KMkfeGRh6AkDtuLhfwd8+UK95MAG
SWQQE+rwbbxu03eC76WUVjikaZd630mWWeSJ5qcLAg2PhI5aE5P1wqEwzA03toU/
OyDnvDUvA/LOltB8RS9tFH8MPWJ8muJBUJExfKNraDf6MKXp9z7w24fZdHlDcs6t
38dmhUxTspZ+XyU7l5Rxbx8KVfnKlfLVtmJBYvAQnOUZL8XEUpYfLlmZsdnyWEJB
2oRilkfj+6+W723w0XvAUXuUcC5GAIlw+pm8KWSu2FLi5fqqBzQODiTB0dkOP4DM
vyMtrQybqj4PWVaStzC8qzAPuQ5pfqi/Ykov3tSq0kQ2jtoh5qReV1DL7j+eOyTI
5LMcFN3fBdlSJGLCerr4muAmJEcmynKsiz0037vh04E5g1zh1XupgK83Sbz18Vmt
wrDezIqItXEZyCjY8ooNzTMDb+YlD3d506EzhEm9m90iq3JyAX+xbNIZEqsJW7X1
Szwl8xtrMHA/f/ZHOIx4RQ+i2fd71QZawYCP230++/v0B9GjJ8ksad3KHnfe6DwX
7+1i1PRLQdO+2VnGbdCS7bDZvp//XN4XgOjI72jeh5T9KIO13gSz357/DSGXv0Eh
iSEhvqCXV9t9ZTFfHGZS
=Vwmw
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----