supercollider-sc3-plugins_3.7.0~beta+git20151221.f978dc2~repack-4_amd64.changes REJECTED

[Hanno Zulla]

Hi Thorsten,

Thank you for your review. We have reviewed the copyright file and
indeed found a mistake that has been fixed for the recently uploaded
version -5 of the package.

Allow me to clarify this problem you mentioned:

> unfortunately you forgot the CC-BY-SA 3.0 license mentioned in
>  supercollider-sc3-plugins/source/ATK/sc/README

The upstream github repo <https://github.com/supercollider/sc3-plugins>
contains git submodules referring to two libraries, ATK and nova-simd.

For Debian, upstream has added a configure setting that allows compiling
the sc3 plugins against Debian's own ATK library, making the embedded
code copy obsolete. ATK has since been removed for the repacked Debian
source package.

However, some source files (e.g. ./source/ATK/sc/README) still refer to
the copyright of the ATK library and the ATK filters that come with it,
but these do not apply to the repacked Debian source package.

<https://github.com/supercollider/sc3-plugins/issues/61>

> unfortunately you forgot the CC-BY-SA 3.0 license mentioned in
>  supercollider-sc3-plugins/source/ATK/sc/HelpSource/Other/ATKDocsLicensing.schelp

True, this has been fixed. Sorry.

As an additional note, the author of the nova-simd library has requested
to not have his library distributed as a separate Debian package, it is
thus included as an embedded copy.

<https://github.com/timblechmann/nova-simd/issues/5>

I hope to have cleared up all open questions. If you have questions
about the package or the packaging decisions made, please respond to
Petter or me.

Kind regards,

Hanno