[Pkg-openldap-devel] Bug#803197: libldap built against GNUTLS breaks SOGo

[Ryan Tandy]

On Tue, Oct 27, 2015 at 02:54:10PM -0700, Ryan Tandy wrote:
>Can you please generate that trace again with libgnutls28-dbg 
>installed, so that we can see more details?

#0  close () at ../sysdeps/unix/syscall-template.S:81
#1  0x00007f2d3a300013 in _rnd_system_entropy_deinit () at rnd-common.c:254
#2  0x00007f2d3a300126 in wrap_nettle_rnd_deinit (ctx=<optimized out>) at rnd.c:157
#3  0x00007f2d3a2612b6 in _gnutls_global_deinit (destructor=0) at gnutls_global.c:364
#4  0x00007f2d3a27225f in gnutls_global_set_mutex (init=0x3, deinit=0x0, lock=0x7f2d3a53ce08 <gnutls_rnd_ctx>,
    unlock=0x7f2d391bbaa0 <tlsg_mutex_unlock>) at locks.c:60
#5  0x00007f2d391b9d66 in tls_init (impl=0x7f2d393d2440 <ldap_int_tls_impl>) at tls2.c:170
#6  0x00007f2d391bae53 in ldap_int_tls_start (ld=ld at entry=0x7f2d3fe88b60, conn=conn at entry=0x7f2d3fe91fd0,
    srv=srv at entry=0x7f2d3fe889b0) at tls2.c:838
#7  0x00007f2d39194f6d in ldap_int_open_connection (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, conn=0x7f2d3fe91fd0, srv=0x7f2d3fe889b0,
    async=<optimized out>) at open.c:448
#8  0x00007f2d391a81bd in ldap_new_connection (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, srvlist=0x0, srvlist at entry=0x7f2d3fe88ca8,
    use_ldsb=978570760, use_ldsb at entry=1, connect=0, bind=0x0, m_req=0, m_res=0) at request.c:484
#9  0x00007f2d3919464a in ldap_open_defconn (ld=ld at entry=0x7f2d3fe88b60) at open.c:41
#10 0x00007f2d391a95e8 in ldap_send_initial_request (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, msgtype=<optimized out>, dn=<optimized out>,
    ber=0x7f2d3fe90f80, msgid=1) at request.c:130
#11 0x00007f2d3919def5 in ldap_sasl_bind (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, dn=0x7f2d3fe90f28 "uid=ryan,dc=example,dc=com",
    mechanism=0x0, cred=0x7ffe77d8a7f0, sctrls=0x7f2d3a53bfa0 <global_init_mutex>, cctrls=0x7f2d3fe90f80,
    msgidp=0x7ffe77d8a784) at sasl.c:148
#12 0x00007f2d3919e46b in ldap_sasl_bind_s (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, dn=0x7f2d3fe90f28 "uid=ryan,dc=example,dc=com",
    mechanism=0x0, cred=0x7ffe77d8a7f0, sctrls=0x0, cctrls=0x7ffe77d8a2f0, servercredp=0x0) at sasl.c:182
#13 0x00007f2d3919ecd2 in ldap_simple_bind_s (ld=0x7f2d3fe88b60, dn=0x7f2d3fe90f28 "uid=ryan,dc=example,dc=com",
    passwd=0x7f2d3fe90f68 "test") at sbind.c:113

http://sources.debian.net/src/gnutls28/3.3.8-6%2Bdeb8u3/lib/nettle/rnd-common.c/#L254

http://sources.debian.net/src/gnutls28/3.3.8-6%2Bdeb8u3/lib/locks.c/#L60

So that's very much not great, and worth looking at again from upstream 
PoV whether we actually need to be doing the gnutls_global_set_mutex 
stuff. (Especially in light of the comment above it: "Do not call this 
function from a library [...]") This in some ways a recurrence of the 
"whose job is it to initialize libraries with global state?" problem 
that we had with gcrypt, not so long ago.

The really problematic bit, though, is this:

https://github.com/inverse-inc/sope/blob/e870145b7ed381c1bdef5945075ed48948b86d5b/sope-appserver/NGObjWeb/WOWatchDogApplicationMain.m#L1014

The order of operations here is:

1. libraries are loaded
2. gnutls' constructor does the global init, open("/dev/urandom") -> 3
3. WOWatchDogApplicationMain runs, closes everything
4. libldap goes to set up gnutls
5. gnutls prepares to re-init itself, closes the remembered urandom fd
6. things go downhill from here.

Actually this exact scenario is mentioned on a gnutls author's blog:

http://nmav.gnutls.org/2014/12/a-quick-overview-of-gnutls-development.html

There were some patches pulled into gnutls in jessie to address an 
application closing the urandom socket and then calling 
gnutls_global_init again, but no such handling around 
gnutls_global_*de*init.

http://sources.debian.net/src/gnutls28/3.3.8-6%2Bdeb8u3/debian/patches/35_recheck_urandom_fd.diff/

So: this could be addressed in libldap, by not calling 
gnutls_global_set_mutex any more, or in sope, by not closing fds so 
aggressively at startup. I admit I didn't look as deeply at the history 
of that code in libldap as I could have, when I updated it for gnutls28; 
I'll do that now.

Ludovic, thoughts from your end?