Bug#825394: shim screen etc?

John Brooks john.lists at fastquake.com
Sat May 28 20:45:28 BST 2016


 > Since the number of commands that start such a process is limited to
 > screen/tmux/nohup, these could just be shimmed to do whatever's
 > needed to let them keep running past logout.

I think implementing a workaround like that would just confuse the 
situation even more. I can easily imagine hours wasted digging around in 
/etc trying to figure out why some programs work properly and others don't.

 > Course it would make more sense to have a proper API that such programs
 > can use themselves.

That's an even worse idea, because then we're making programs work 
around systemd's decisions. Interoperability and maintenance nightmare, 
not to mention the numerous philosophical objections I could think of.

If this were a badly needed architectural change, it might be worth 
considering these ideas. But there's so little benefit to this behaviour 
that it's simply not worth making the effort to adapt to.




More information about the Pkg-systemd-maintainers mailing list