[Piuparts-devel] piuparts-analyze needs to ignore BinNMU suffix in version numbers (\+b\d+$)

[Andreas Beckmann]

On 2011-11-19 03:07, Mika Pflüger wrote:
> I don't know if my attempt to automatically detect packages having the
> exact same bug again actually works - have you ever got an output of 
> bts found #bug version
> ?

I'm not exactly sure what you mean here ...

> I haven't seen such a case, so that I test with a logfile where I
> simply replace the version number, but in reality there could be much
> more differences... Holger suggested just assuming that every package
> that fails piuparts again has the same error, maybe that would be a
> better approach.

IMO, automatically setting doing bts found is a bad idea, it needs
manual inspection, e.g.

libdspam7-drv-pgsql/3.10.1+dfsg-3: Maybe the bug was filed earlier:
566559 against libdspam7-drv-pgsql/3.6.8-9.3

http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=566559
* is fixed + closed, but not yet archived
* is about a postinst failure

http://piuparts.debian.org/sid/bugged/libdspam7-drv-pgsql_3.10.1+dfsg-3.log
* leaves unowned files after removal
* is a completely different issue from #566559

On the other hand I reopened
http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=635550
because it still does not fix the old issue

Andreas

PS: output after merging the lessnoise branch - looks better now:

Moving fail/apt-p2p_0.1.6.log to bugged
frontaccounting/2.2.10-3: Maybe the bug was filed earlier: 595591
against frontaccounting/2.2.10-2
Moving fail/cricket_1.0.5-14.log to bugged
Moving fail/cups_1.5.0-12.log to bugged
Moving fail/automysqlbackup_2.5-6.log to bugged
Moving fail/debdelta_0.44.log to bugged
Moving fail/blootbot_1.2.0-6.3.log to bugged
Moving fail/flashybrid_0.16.log to bugged
Moving fail/gsm-utils_1.10-13.log to bugged
Moving fail/killer_0.90-7.log to bugged
Moving fail/systemd_37-1.log to bugged
libdspam7-drv-pgsql/3.10.1+dfsg-3: Maybe the bug was filed earlier:
566559 against libdspam7-drv-pgsql/3.6.8-9.3
Moving fail/buildbot-slave_0.8.5-1.log to bugged
Moving fail/libpam-shield_0.9.2-3.2.log to bugged
Moving fail/lpr_1:2008.05.17+nmu1.log to bugged
Moving fail/dnscache-run_1:1.05-8.log to bugged
clamav-getfiles/2.0-6: Maybe the bug was filed earlier: 502751 against
clamav-getfiles/2.0-4
Moving fail/clamav-getfiles_2.0-6.log to bugged
Moving fail/netams_3.4.5-2.log to bugged
Moving fail/pdns-recursor_3.3-2.log to bugged
Moving fail/iceweasel_8.0-3.log to bugged
Moving fail/pdns-server_2.9.22-9.log to bugged
Moving fail/desktop-profiles_1.4.15+nmu1.log to bugged
Moving fail/debtorrent_0.1.10.log to bugged
Moving fail/infon-server_0~r198-4.log to bugged
Moving fail/javascript-common_8.log to bugged
Moving fail/dict-wn_1:3.0-26.log to bugged
Moving fail/pmw_4.22-4.log to bugged
Moving fail/emile-bootblocks_0.11-2.log to bugged
Moving fail/jffnms_0.9.1-1.log to bugged
Moving fail/wiican_0.3.1-4.log to bugged
Moving fail/libfox-1.6-dev_1.6.44-1.1+b1.log to bugged
Moving fail/rabbitmq-server_2.6.1-1.log to bugged
Moving fail/yate_2.2.0-1~dfsg-1.1+b1.log to bugged